A comparison of complex expert-based assessment versus quickscan assessment

Fleur Marchand, Lies Debruyne, Ludwig Lauwers

Onderzoeksoutput: Hoofdstuk in Boek/Rapport/CongresprocedureC1: Artikels in proceedings van wetenschappelijke congressen, die niet inbegrepen zijn in A1, A2, A3 of P1peer review

2 Downloads (Pure)


Past decades, various sustainability assessments emerged, ranging from very complex expert-based assessments to quick scan ones. The former type is based on expert information and an extensive data demand, the latter on information gathered instantly from the farmer. This research compares both types while using the following criteria: i) the design approach and characteristics, ii) the critical succes factors for implementation put forward by De Mey et al. (2011), iii) results in the field and evaluation by the end-users. As an example for an expert-based assessment, we used MOTIFS (Meul et al. 2008) designed for dairy farming in Flanders. We applied this tool on Flemish dairy farms within the EU-Interreg project Dairyman. The OCIS Public Goods tool (Gerard et al. 2011), designed for organic dairy farms in Great Britain was used as example of a quickscan method. During the EU project SOLID, the tool was adjusted for the entire European region and applied on organic dairy farms. This research determines the strenghts and weaknesses of both types of sustainability assessment systems. This will result in suggestions on which type of sustainablity assessment is relevant depending on the case, related to the critical succes factors such as attitude of model users, time and data availability, user friendliness, communication aid, etc. Researchers and practitioners can use this information when developing or selecting, and possibly modifying, an appropriate tool for their goals.
Oorspronkelijke taalEngels
TitelProceedings of the 10th IFSA symposium : Producing and reproducing farming systems. New modes of organization for sustainable food systems of tomorrow.
Aantal pagina’s10
PublicatiestatusGepubliceerd - 2012
Evenement10th European IFSA Symposium. Producing and Reproducing Farming Systems (2012) - Aarhus, Denemarken
Duur: 1-jul.-20124-jul.-2012


Bekijk de onderzoeksthema's van 'A comparison of complex expert-based assessment versus quickscan assessment'. Samen vormen ze een unieke vingerafdruk.

Dit citeren